|
For couples to prevent unintended pregnancy after unprotected intercourse, emergency
contraception offers a means. Yet unprotected intercourse also increases the risks of
contracting a sexually transmitted disease (STD). Are there emergency measures that can be
taken to reduce this risk after exposure?
Yes, experts say. However, these measures have limitations and are recommended only for
certain groups of people, such as women who are victims of sexual assault. Emergency
treatment of STDs is not recommended for routine use.
"The principal problem [with emergency treatment] is the multitude of STDs,"
says Dr. Robert Johnson, a medical epidemiologist with the Division of STD Prevention at
the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). "There isn't a single drug
that can treat all STDs. The viral agents cannot be treated. Coming up with a regimen is
problematic."
There are more than 20 types of sexually transmitted diseases. While latex condoms, used
consistently and correctly, can reduce the risks of all of them, no single drug can
successfully treat all of them.
Combinations of antibiotics may be used to reduce a woman's risks of infection from some
bacterial STDs following sexual assault. Genital washing and medications have shown some
effectiveness in preventing STDs among men serving in the military. Douches, used by many
women to cleanse the vagina, may not help prevent STDs and may actually promote infection
in cases where contamination is introduced.
Worldwide, an estimated 250 million new cases of STDs occur annually.1
Most scientists now agree that STD infection increases an individual's risk of contracting
HIV, the virus that causes AIDS. There is evidence that STDs that cause genital sores,
such as herpes, chancroid and syphilis, can enhance the risks of HIV transmission by
creating a site of entry for the AIDS virus. Other STDs, which do not produce ulcers but
do produce inflammation, may also increase susceptibility to HIV.2
Because latex condoms can prevent transmission of both bacterial and viral STDs, and
because antibiotics can successfully treat bacterial STDs once a diagnosis has been made,
research to find a method of emergency STD prevention -- one that could be used after
unprotected sexual intercourse but before symptoms develop -- has been limited.
However, research is under way to develop microbicides, which would kill both bacterial
and viral STD pathogens. Some researchers have speculated that these products, designed
for use prior to sexual intercourse to prevent infection, might also be used for
postcoital or emergency STD prevention. (See related article, page 15.)
"The need for such a product is evidenced by emerging data concerning the widespread
prevalence of non-consensual and coercive sex in women's lives, even within married and
consensual unions," write Christopher Elias of the Population Council and Lori Heise
of the Health and Development Policy Project. "A postcoital method might also have
some utility for women, especially adolescents, in communities where 'planning' to have
sex is unacceptable."3
Postcoital STD treatment could also be helpful for couples who use condoms as a means of
STD prevention but experience condom breakage or slippage, much as emergency contraception
is used to prevent pregnancy when a couple experiences condom failure.
Sexual assault
For women who are the victims of sexual assault or non-consensual sex, the CDC has
developed guidelines for emergency STD treatment. The guidelines recommend a combination
of antibiotics, given within hours after sexual intercourse. This combination is designed
to prevent the infections most commonly diagnosed after sexual assault -- trichomoniasis,
chlamydia, gonorrhea and vaginal bacteriosis.
The CDC recommends: 125 milligrams of ceftriaxone injected intramuscularly in a single
dose; two grams of metronidazole orally in a single dose; and 100 milligrams of
doxycycline taken orally twice a day for seven days.4
The CDC also recommends that health-care providers counsel the client about symptoms of
STDs and the need for her to return to the clinic if these occur. Providers should counsel
the client to use condoms until the antibiotic treatment is complete, to prevent the
possibility of any STD transmission to her partner.
If available, clients should be given a vaccine to protect against Hepatitis B. If
laboratory tests are available for STDs, the client should return for follow-up
examinations at two weeks and 12 weeks after the sexual assault.
The likelihood of contracting an STD after sexual intercourse is less than the risk of
becoming pregnant. Fewer than one in five people are infected with an STD at any given
time, while nine out of 10 women under age 35 are fertile and could become pregnant.5 The use of antibiotics as a preventive measure is often done
for psychological reasons as well as biological ones. The client, who has already
undergone the physical and emotional trauma of assault, may have one less consequence to
worry about if she takes antibiotics.
There is some risk a woman will acquire HIV infection after sexual assault, but the CDC
says the risks are very low. There are no emergency measures a health-care provider can
take to reduce a woman's risk of HIV in this situation. Providers should offer HIV
counseling and testing to clients, but some experts recommend that this be done during a
return visit to the clinic, not during the initial visit when the client is frightened and
upset.
Outside of use to prevent the development of STDs among sexual assault victims, the use of
antibiotics for emergency STD prevention in the larger population is regarded by most
experts as an unnecessary and an expensive use of scarce medical resources.
"Emergency treatment will result in the overtreatment of people who are not
infected," says Dr. Jonathan Zenilman, associate professor of medicine in the
Infectious Disease Division of Johns Hopkins University in the United States. Given that
some STDs have developed a resistance to certain antibiotics, treatment before diagnosis
is not recommended.
Military experience
The use of postcoital emergency treatment for STDs has had some success in the U.S.
military. During World War I, military officials tried to reduce the incidence of STDs
through educational campaigns that emphasized the need for servicemen to be "100
percent efficient to win the war." Military personnel were encouraged to practice
abstinence to prevent sexually transmitted diseases.
Servicemen who did engage in sexual activity with prostitutes were told to return to their
military base and report for emergency treatment within three hours after sexual
intercourse. The procedure involved several steps. First, the soldier urinated, then
washed his genitals with soap and water, followed by bichloride of mercury. A medical
attendant inspected the soldier's genital area, then injected Protargol, which contains
silver protein, into the penis. The soldier would urinate five minutes later. Finally,
calomel ointment was rubbed onto the penis, and the penis was wrapped in wax paper. The
soldier was not to urinate for at least four to five hours after treatment.
To further reduce the incidence of sexually transmitted disease during World War I, U.S.
soldiers were given an emergency treatment packet they could administer themselves. This
was done on an experimental basis for soldiers who did not have access to a health clinic.
The packet contained calomel ointment, carbolic acid and camphor.
Military health officials estimated this treatment could be 99.6 percent effective in
preventing syphilis, gonorrhea and chancroid. Statistics on the success of military
efforts to reduce STDs were not published. However, military officials estimate that
several million men received emergency STD treatment.
During World War II, the U.S. military sought to reduce the incidence of STDs by offering
educational programs, emergency STD treatment and condoms for STD prevention. With the
discovery that antibiotics could effectively treat bacterial STDs, and the knowledge that
condoms could prevent STD transmission, the use of emergency STD clinics diminished.6
In the 1970s, a study among some 500 U.S. male sailors who had sexual intercourse with
women while on shore leave in the western Pacific concluded that STD infection rates did
not decrease significantly if a man urinated within 30 minutes after intercourse or if he
washed his genitals within an hour.7 Another study among 1,000
male sailors found that 200 mg of minocycline, taken orally a few hours after intercourse,
offered some protection against the subsequent development of gonorrhea. However,
researchers did not recommend widespread use of the antibiotic because drug-resistant
strains of gonorrhea could develop.8
Vaginal douching
Because many women practice routine vaginal douching for hygienic purposes, there has
been speculation that postcoital douching might reduce the incidence of STDs. Studies have
shown that douching may not offer any type of protection against STDs. In fact, it may
promote some types of reproductive tract infections.
While vaginal douching may decrease the risks of gonorrhea, it may increase the risks of
pelvic inflammatory disease and ectopic pregnancy.9 A study of
more than 600 women in the United States found those who douched were more likely to have
risk factors for STDs, including multiple sexual partners and first sexual intercourse at
an early age. However, others say it is difficult to determine whether douching increases
a woman's risk of infection or whether douching is simply a common practice among women at
risk of STDs for other reasons.10
Normally, the pH in the vagina is low (acidic), but the pH levels change during
intercourse with ejaculation, menses, estrogen deficiency, menopause and bacterial
vaginosis. Researchers believe that pH levels in the vagina may play an important role in
STD transmission.
Several small studies have examined the changes in normal vaginal microorganisms after
douching. One study of 20 women in the United States found that small amounts of a douche
preparation containing the antiseptic, chlorhexidine gluconate, did not significantly
alter the vaginal flora after 30 days of use.11 A small study
at the Universita di Sassari in Italy evaluated seven vaginal douche preparations to
determine their in vitro effects on lactobacilli, a bacteria commonly found in the vagina.
Lactobacilli produce hydrogen peroxide, which inhibits the growth of some pathogens,
possibly STD pathogens.12 Researchers concluded that frequent
use of these douches could change the composition of the normal vaginal flora.13 A study of 10 women in the United States, which compared two
types of douche preparations, found that those containing acetic acid (the acid in
vinegar) caused short-term minor changes in the vaginal flora, while solutions containing
povidone-iodine (Betadine) caused significant changes in the vaginal flora, which could
increase the risks of infections and possibly the risks of pelvic inflammatory disease.14
The use of soft drinks as a postcoital douche is frequently suggested as a folk remedy to
prevent pregnancy after unprotected sex, but is not effective since sperm enter the cervix
within seconds after ejaculation. A study of seven men in Nigeria examined the effects of
four different types of soft drinks on in vitro motility of sperm. The study found that
one brand of drink, Krest bitter lemon, immobilized all sperm within one minute. The study
did not, however, explore microbicidal effects.15 A study
conducted in the United States investigated the spermicidal effects of Coca-Cola and found
that different formulations of the soft drink did reduce sperm motility.16
A separate study of cola drinks found little effect on sperm motility. Researchers
suggested the introduction of these liquids into the vagina might cause infection.17
Some researchers suggest that a microbicidal postcoital douche might be more culturally
acceptable than condoms, which require negotiation between partners. A postcoital douche
of tea or beer, which has a low pH, or sour milk, which contains lactobacilli that result
in low pH levels, might offer protection against STDs, including AIDS, researchers
suggest.
Soap and water
Genital washing has been suggested as a means to prevent STD transmission to men.
Studies of military personnel in World War I and World War II found that washing with soap
and water soon after exposure to STDs helped prevent chancroid.
In sub-Saharan Africa, genital washing has been theoretically proposed as a way to reduce
STD and HIV incidence. Lack of circumcision in men may be a risk factor for development of
chancroid, a common cause of genital ulcer disease in Africa. Genital ulcer disease
appears to be a risk factor for contracting HIV. Health advocates suggest that education
about postcoital and precoital washing with instructions on how to clean the area beneath
the foreskin of the penis might be one way to reduce the incidence of STDs in east,
central and southern Africa, where male circumcision is less common and genital ulcer
disease more common than in west Africa.18
But a study in Singapore, which questioned 100 prostitutes about methods they used to
prevent sexually transmitted diseases, found that postcoital washing with antiseptic
solutions had no STD prevention effect for this group of women.19
-- Barbara Barnett
Footnotes
- Crosignani PG, Diczfalusy E, Newton J, et al. Sexually
transmitted diseases. Hum Reprod 1992; 9:1330-34.
- Mauck CR, Cordero M, Gabelnick H, et al., eds. Barrier
Contraceptives: Current Status and Future Prospects. Proceedings of the Fourth
Contraceptive Research and Development Program International Workshop, March 22-25, 1993,
Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic. New York: John Wiley and Sons Inc., 1994.
- Elias CJ, Heise LL. Challenges for the development of
female-controlled vaginal microbicides. AIDS 1994; 8:1-9.
- U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 1993 Sexually
Transmitted Diseases Treatment Guidelines. Atlanta: CDC, 1993.
- Cates W Jr., Stone KM. Family planning, sexually
transmitted diseases and contraceptive choice; a literature update -- part I. Fam Plann
Perspect 1992; 24(12):75-84.
- Brandt AM. No Magic Bullet: A Social History of
Venereal Disease in the United States Since 1880. New York: Oxford University Press,
1985.
- Hooper RR, Reynolds GH, Jones OG, et al. Cohort study of
venereal disease. I: the risk of gonorrhea transmission from infected women to men. Am
J Epidemiol 1978; 108(2):136-44.
- Harrison WO, Hooper RR, Wiesner PJ, et al. A trial of
minocycline given after exposure to prevent gonorrhea. N Engl J Med 1979; 300(19):
1074-78.
- Chow WH, Daling JR, Weiss NS, et al. Vaginal douching as
a potential risk for tubal ectopic pregnancy. Am Obstet Gynecol 1985; 153(7):72.
Wolner-Hanssen P, Eschenbach D, Paavonen J, et al. Association between vaginal douching
and acute pelvic inflammatory disease. JAMA 1990; 263:1936-41.
- Rosenberg MJ, Phillips RS, Holmes MD. Vaginal douching:
who and why? J Reproduct Med 1991; 36(10):753-58. Rosenberg MJ, Phillips RS. Does
douching promote ascending infection? J Reproduct Med 1992; 37(11):930-38.
- Shubair M, Stanek R, White S, et al. Effects of
chlorhexidine gluconate on normal vaginal flora. Gyn Obstet Investigation 1992;
34(4):229-33.
- Klebanoff SJ, Hillier SJ, Eschenbach DA, et al. Control
of the microbial flora of the vagina by H2O2-generating lactobacilli. J Infect Dis
1991; 164(1):94-100.
- Julian C, Piu L, Gavini E, et al. In vitro
antibacterial activity of antiseptics against vaginal lactobacilli. European J Clinical
Microbiology Infect Dis 1992; 11(12):1166-69.
- Onderdonk AB, Delaney ML, Hinkson PL, et al.
Quantitative and qualitative effects of douche preparations on vaginal microflora. Obstet
Gynecol 1992; 80:333-38.
- Nwoha PU. The immobilization of all spermatozoa in
vitro by bitter lemon drink and the effect of alkaline pH. Contraception 1992;
46(6):537-42.
- Umpierre SA, Hill JA, Anderson DJ. Effect of 'Coke' on
sperm motility. N Engl J Med 1985; 313(21):2.
- Hong CY, Shieh CC, Wu P, et al. The spermicidal potency
of Coca-Cola and Pepsi-Cola. Hum Toxicol 1987; 6(5):395-96.
- O'Farrell N. Soap and water prophylaxis for limiting
genital ulcer disease and HIV-1 infection in men in sub-Saharan Africa. Genitourin Med 1993;
69:297-300.
- Bradbeer CS, Thin RN, Tan T, et al. Prophylaxis against
infection in Singaporean prostitutes. Genitourin Med 1988; 64(1):52-53.
For more information, visit Family Health International's Website at www.fhi.org
Go to FHI's Network |
Copyright